In the playoffs, the only thing that matters is winning.
Playing the role as underdogs on Thursday night in Orlando, FC Cincinnati fought back to take the lead in the second half and never looked back. It was arguably less than pretty, but it’s all about surviving and advancing in the playoffs.
Now FC Cincinnati are facing what would be the tallest task of this playoffs—a best-of-three series against Nashville SC. The Tennessee unit won the Supporters’ Shield, setting the MLS points record this season.
FC Cincinnati
In the best-of-three era, FC Cincinnati have fared quite well. The Orange and Blue are 2-1 in the three years of this playoff configuration. Pat Noonan led them to series wins over Red Bull New York in 2023 and last season against Columbus Crew. Their only loss came in 2024 at the hands of New York City FC.
Now FC Cincinnati travel to Nashville Sunday afternoon to kick off their three-match series. In the two matches FCC played against Nashville this season, the Orange and Blue lost both by a combined scored of 6-0.
While victorious on Thursday, FCC did not keep a clean sheet. Miles Robinson and Nick Hagglund had a rough night and were replaced at halftime. The Cincinnati defense has been the ever-present topic at the forefront of the discussion all season long.
In order to have a chance at winning this opening match, Noonan is going t0 have to pick the three guys he thinks can communicate and defend as a unit. While Noonan has options to play at the center-back position, health concerns will linger. Luckily, both Robinson and Hagglund will be available for selection, but Teenage Hadebe (leg) remains out.
However, there are a lot of positives that FCC carry into this matchup. Goalkeeper Roman Celentano played out of this world on Thursday night, making a couple outstanding saves to keep FC Cincinnati in the match. His save in the 24th minute on Marco Pasalic’s header could have been a nominee for save of the season if it happened in the regular season.
The postseason version of Evander also arrived. The Brazilian captain entered Thursday’s match with zero goals in his previous five playoff matches. If FC Cincinnati wants to make a deep playoff run, they are going to need Evander to continue his scoring ways. While the backline is certainly very important to FCC’s success in this best of three, Evander’s play is also high up on that list.
Nashville SC
Nashville SC start their quest of being only the ninth team in MLS history to win both the Supporters’ Shield and MLS Cup in the same season. They have not played a match since Decision Day against FC Cincinnati back on November 7th. This Nashville side is far and away the best defensive team in the league as well, having only surrendered 25 goals all season long.
It should be no surprise that they were so defensively sound. A trio of Nashville defenders were the nominees for Defender of the Year, with Maxwell Woledzi taking home the award. The stout defense is a huge reason why Nashville set a record for wins at home this season, racking up 15 in the process. Nashville also didn’t lose at home this season, becoming just the seventh team to ever pull that feat off and the second time the club have done that.
The Boys in Gold aren’t just great at defending. This is a side that scored the third-most goals this season, only finishing behind Inter Miami and Vancouver Whitecaps.
However, Nashville will be looking to avoid a repeat of history. Inter Miami set the MLS record for points in a season in 2024. In a shocking upset, Atlanta United beat the Shield winners in the first round that year. Nashville will look to avoid the same fate that befell Inter Miami.
Keys to the match
Nashville SC: For Nashville, it is pretty simple—play your game.
BJ Callaghan’s men have a formula that worked all season at home. There is no need to change any tactics or rotate the squad at all. Everyone is rested, and all players are available for selection. On paper and on film, they have been the better team than FC Cincinnati. They just have to go out and show it in the playoffs.
FC Cincinnati: Defending is obviously going to play a huge part in winning this match. However, FCC have yet to score a goal against Nashville this season. Forcing penalties at 0-0 in every match is a possible route, but that’s not going to be a winning formula. FC Cincinnati have to get the first goal to set the tone.
Match Info
Where: GEODIS Park
When: Sunday November 22nd, 4 PM
Watch: Apple TV+
Listen: ESPN 1530 w/ Tommy Gelehrter and Kevin McCloskey
