(Updated with quotes from Noonan.)
On a day that started dreary and gray—a day where Cincinnati lost its princess—the Orange & Blue managed to brighten it for everyone in the Queen City.
FC Cincinnati move into the first round of the MLS Cup Playoffs after defeating Orlando City SC 3-1 in the play-in match. Evander broke his playoff cold spell with a brace and an assist, while Samuel Gidi iced the match with a late golazo.
“Nice to keep playing, not how we kind of drew it up with personnel, with some of the moves that we made,” Pat Noonan admitted after the match. “But I credit the entirety of the group for just being ready. We have hard
decisions of who’s in the 20, who’s not, who’s coming in, and I think tonight was an easy one where you go down on the road … we get the goal back, at halftime we have a couple guys that are dealing with some issues that you have to make some unplanned changes, but that’s life.
“That’s been our reality, and I think the guys did an incredible job of just adapting, adjusting, and then winning an important game.”
While Cincinnati had made postseason play for the fifth straight year, it wasn’t easy, getting in as the nine seed after a 2-0 loss to Nashville on Decision Day.
The weight felt even more oppressive after it was announced that Fiona, the Cincinnati Zoo’s prized hippo and a symbol of the Queen City herself, passed away Thursday afternoon.
Orlando were riding a big Decision Day win over New England, but needed a clean sheet to do so. The win pushed the Lions past Cincinnati in the standings, giving them the home start.
The pressure was on FC Cincinnati to provide the best Starting XI with the available pieces. Both Kevin Denkey (Togo) and Bryan Ramirez (Ecuador) returned after recent international play overseas. However, the two started on the bench to begin the match.
Teenage Hadebe (leg) has been scheduled to miss an extended period of time, but Nick Hagglund and Miles Robinson both returned to the back line. Tyrell Malacia and David Doudera took their places on the edges, while Evander took Denkey’s slot above the formation.
Orlando were missing midfielder Braian Ojeda (lower extremity) and Wilder Cartagena (thigh), despite their questionable status. Griffin Dorsey returned to the starting lineup after his own injury spell, while Iago returned to the back line after card suspension. Forward Justin Ellis, fresh from his stint with the USMNT, returned to the bench.
First half
Cincinnati love a good early goal in Orlando and almost scored right from the drop. Tom Barlow found himself wide open streaking in the box in the first minute, only for fullback Vinícius Nogueira to get a foot in to disrupt the shot.
While FCC enjoyed possession in the first 15 minutes, Orlando dominated the counterattack, often through their left wing. Had Roman Celentano not been on his better game, the scoring could have gotten out of hand.
A cross from Martin Ojeda in the 24th minute found Marco Pasalic in the box, but Celentano made himself wide to swat the header away. In retrospect, this could have been Roman’s best save of the year.
However, goalkeepers cannot save everything.
In the 26th minute, Eduard Atuesta caught Robinson and Hagglund off their marks and looped a pass to a streaking Ivan Angulo. Angulo slowed strategically to target Ojeda in the box, and the Argentine forward slotted his shot past Celentano.
The lead could have grown had Celentano not made his four first-half saves. Ojeda again beat the back line in the 37th minute, but Celentano’s frame forced an early saved shot, and Ojeda was unable to keep the follow-up on frame afterward.
The Cincinnati goalkeeper had six saves over the 90 minutes.
It took some smart set-piece play for Cincinnati to draw level. In the 41st minute, Evander found Pavel Bucha with a quick corner kick. The Czech midfielder beat Pasalic into the box, forcing a tug of the jersey for a penalty kick.
Evander’s converted kick in the 43rd minute—his first MLS Cup playoff goal—knotted the score at halftime.
While Cincinnati shared possession by halftime, Orlando was much more the dangerous squad. The Lions outpointed FCC on shots (10-4) and shots on target (5-2). However, Cincinnati took advantage of the set pieces, taking five corner kicks to Orlando’s one.
Second half
Noonan rolled the dice to start the second half by making two risky subs. Hagglund and Robinson were lifted for Jose Martinez and Alvas Powell, leaving the back line without a true center back.
No matter.
Evander broke the game open with his second in the 50th minute. Barlow found himself free after Iago failed to intercept a pass from Nwobodo. While Crepeau saved the first attempt, Barlow managed to tap the rebound over to Evander. The FCC captain slotted home the shot to give Cincinnati their first lead.
Orlando played pressing football after the goal. However, FCC played smart low-block defense to keep the ball from reaching Griezmann and to keep Ojeda outside the box.
However, the inflection point may not have been a play at all, but rather a substitution pattern.
Interim coach Martin Perelman opted to make three substitutions midway into the half. However, he used two windows in the span of two minutes to get it done. The third and final window was spent in the 75th minute to bring Daryl Dike on.
The pressure almost split the defense in the 77th minute. Ojeda had a free look at net, only for his shot to be blocked off the line by Gidi.
In the scrum off the carom, Dike came up limp with a hamstring injury. The lack of a window meant that Dike could not be subbed off, hampering Orlando’s attack.
In the 85th minute, Cincinnati drove the final nail. Gidi received a feed from Evander, getting space to push a curling effort past his defender and Crepeau’s left. The midfielder’s second of the year shut the door on Orlando’s season.
Noonan has sights already on Nashville. “We got a lot of guys banged up, and as you saw to end the game, it was not an eleven that many would have imagined were seeing out that victory in the positions they were in. So, hopefully, we get some good news on some of the players, and if not, guys are going to do their best to turn it around and be ready to go in Nashville.”
The defense held on for dear life in the second half, but the Orange & Blue rested a good bit of their offense. Denkey, Kenji Mboma Dem, and Ayoub Jabbari rested the full 90 minutes, and all three should be ready for the next test.
The victory stamps FCC’s passport for the first round. Their best-of-three series against Nashville, the East’s #1 seed, starts on Sunday.
Major League Soccer, 2026 MLS Cup Playoffs
Eastern Conference Play-in Match
Orlando City SC vs. FC Cincinnati
Inter.co Stadium, Orlando, FL
Attendance: 17,147
Result: Orlando City SC 1, FC Cincinnati 3.
BOX SCORE
FC Cincinnati Starting XI (3-4-1-2):
Roman Celentano (GK); Miles Robinson (Alvas Powell 46′), Nick Hagglund (Jose Martinez 46′), Kyle Smith; David Doudera (Ender Echenique 68′), Samuel Gidi, Obinna Nwobodo, Tyrell Malacia; Pavel Bucha (Julian Malatini 81′); Tom Barlow, Evander (C) (Bryan Ramirez 87′).
Bench: Evan Louro, Kenji Mboma Dem, Kevin Denkey, Ayoub Jabbari.
Orlando City SC Starting XI (4-4-2):
Maxime Crepeau (GK); Griffin Dorsey (Daryl Dike 75′), David Brekalo, Iago Teodoro (Adrian Marin 53′), Vinicius Nogueira; Marco Pasalic (Justin Ellis 53′), Luis Otavio (Joran Gerbert 55′), Eduard Atuesta, Ivan Angulo; Antoine Griezmann, Martin Ojeda (C).
Bench: Javier Otero, Zakaria Taifi, Bernardo Rhein Goncalves, Tiago, Harvey Sarajian.
Scoring summary:
ORL – Martin Ojeda 26’ (Angulo)
CIN – Evander 43′ (PK)
CIN – Evander 50′ (Barlow)
CIN – Samuel Gidi 87′ (Evander)
Discipline:
YC – Tom Barlow 51′ (CIN, poor sportsmanship)
YC – Pavel Bucha 60′ (CIN, poor sportsmanship)
YC – Obinna Nwobodo ‘ (CIN, foul)
YC – Jose Martinez 76′ (CIN, foul)
YC – Daryl Dike 78′ (ORL, foul)
YC – Ivan Angulo 90+2’ (ORL, foul)
Next Match:
MLS Cup Playoffs, at Nashville SC, Sunday November 22nd, 4pm; Apple+.
